3.5/5 stars -- Kumcergam : Kampungan - Romansa

Category:	Books
Genre:	Comics & Graphic Novels
Author:	Various

Gegara kapan itu mas Edwin dan Rana membicarakan perihal perkomikan Indonesia, gw kemaren iseng ke TMBooks Margonda, Depok. Dan ternyata, gw nemu kumpulan cergam ini (sayangnya masih no.1 doang) di tumpukan.

Buku ini berisi 6 cerita bergambar yang menitik beratkan pada romansa para tokohnya :

1. Melati Revolusi oleh Arif Yuntoro dan Pamudji MS.

Kisah kakak beradik yang sama-sama mencintai seorang gadis. Bersetting di masa perang Revolusi (pokoknya saat Jenderal Mallaby datang ke Surabaya ituh, kalo gak salah mau Pertempuran 10 November). Gambarnya sendiri, mengingatkan gw pada tipikal komik jaman gw SD.

2. Dago by Aprilia Sari dan Beng Rahardian

Gw pribadi mengenal karya mas Beng semenjak kuliah, gegara salah satu temen komunitas diam-diam memendam rasa pada sang artis *rasa kagum, maksudnya :D* Dan Aprilia Sari, ternyata adalah vokalis grup White Shoes and The Couple Company. Artworknya cakep, dengan nuansa abu-abu gitu.

3. Kidung Malam oleh Aji Prasetyo

Salah satu cerita paling apik di kumcer ini. Bersetting di Indonesia tahun 1800-an, gaya penceritaan khas mas Aji dan gambarnya yang super ciamik bener-bener memberikan nuansa tersendiri. Apalagi pas adegan perang dan sang ibu menyanyikan kidung malam untuk buah hati mereka. Dalam kepala gw, terbayang adegan slow-motion dengan alunan tembang Jawa nan mistis. CIAMIK pokoknya

4. Antara Aku, Sahabatku dan Anak Mamak-ku oleh Jon Kobet.

Kisah cerita segitiga dari bumi Riau. Gambarnya sederhana, namun penempatan panelnya nyaman untuk dibaca meski kadang tulisannya buanyak.

5. Resonansi Hati by Papillon Studio

Papillon Studio ini pernah berjaya saat "manga" khas Indonesia sedang marak-maraknya. Kali ini mereka hadir dalam cergam ini, menawarkan cerita yang sangat down-to-earth tentang pencarian makna hidup. Menyentuh, meski endingnya sedikit garing buat gw.

6. Cinta di Senja Hari oleh Hans Jaladara

Gw sama sekali nggak menyangka bahwa "sesepuh" perkomikan nasional ikut menyumbangkan karyanya di sini. Ibarat serial anime, cerita lepas Panji Tengkorak kali ini seperti OVA atau movie, epilog perjalanan sang pendekar dalam mengakhiri kisahnya. Sempat membaca di beberapa review bahwa kisah Panji Tengkorak bukanlah kisah murni action, namun kisah romansa level tinggi. Itulah sebabnya, penuturan kisah kasih dalam cergam ini terasa begitu smooth, manis dan endingnya..nyam..nyam..nyam :>

****

Dua essai dalam cergam ini juga menarik untuk disimak. Salah satunya adalah Jejak Sumir Komik Eropa karya Ifan Ardiansyah Ismail. Beliau ini bertutur tentang perkembangan komik di Indonesia dari masa ke masa. Dan kenapa yang "dipersalahkan" dalam mandeg-nya komik khas Indonesia hanya manga Jepang dan komik Amerika, sedangkan secara halus, komik Eropa malah menyusup ke tengah-tengah kita dengan gencarnya. Namun, tak ada satupun yang mempermasalahkannya, malah merasa bangga bahwa pernah "berkenalan" dengan komik-komik tersebut.

Esai yang renyah dan tepat sasaran, terutama di bagian akhirnya.
Saat ini gw lagi nungguin Komik Kampungan part 2 dan 3, meski pas gw liat jajaran pengisinya, gw enggak kenal satupun :D *dipentung*

delete reply phonay wrote on Jul 11 kenapa klo gambarnya ga komik bego gw ga tertarik ya? mungkin karena jadi mirip lukisan yang kidung malam bagus ya kata2 nya hehehe

edit delete reply darnia wrote on Jul 11 phonay said kenapa klo gambarnya ga komik bego gw ga tertarik ya? mungkin karena jadi mirip lukisan yang kidung malam bagus ya kata2 nya hehehe gw dulunya juga males-malesan kalo baca komik lokal yang serius Tapi gak tau ya..ke sini-sini malah demen bacanya. Jadi bisa liat perbandingan gambar-gambar di komik-komik Indonesia dari dulu sampe sekarang...

delete reply m4s0k3 wrote on Jul 11 gw demen banget yang DAGO sama KIDUNG malam. Merinding bacanya coi. Coba gw bisa ngomik...

edit delete reply darnia wrote on Jul 11 m4s0k3 said gw demen banget yang DAGO sama KIDUNG malam. Merinding bacanya coi. Coba gw bisa ngomik... Yang Dago itu, kalo enggak punya pengalaman sendiri, kayaknya enggak dapet feelnya *ngaca* Jadi, ada pengalaman apakah, bang Yas? *kepo to the max* :>

delete reply m4s0k3 wrote on Jul 11 darnia said Yang Dago itu, kalo enggak punya pengalaman sendiri, kayaknya enggak dapet feelnya *ngaca* Jadi, ada pengalaman apakah, bang Yas? *kepo to the max* :> wakakakaakakkakak.. tau aja budan.. dulu itu, eke galau jalan sendirian ujan-ujan dari BIP sampe Dipati Ukur menyusuri Dago. Biasalah kasih tak sampai *salto mundur*

edit delete reply darnia wrote on Jul 11 m4s0k3 said wakakakaakakkakak.. tau aja budan.. dulu itu, eke galau jalan sendirian ujan-ujan dari BIP sampe Dipati Ukur menyusuri Dago. Biasalah kasih tak sampai *salto mundur* woaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaah..ternyataaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa... *puk puk* Aku kalo Bandung ingetnya nyasar dan wisata kuliner tak sampai :|

delete reply edwinlives4ever wrote on Jul 11 darnia said Kidung Malam oleh Aji Prasetyo Salah satu cerita paling apik di kumcer ini. Yes, the best one. But there are few mistakes in the lyric of Kidung Rumeksa Ing Wengi.

edit delete reply darnia wrote on Jul 11 edwinlives4ever said Yes, the best one. But there are few mistakes in the lyric of Kidung Rumeksa Ing Wengi. hehehhe...tapi di antara semua komik yang ada (nyuwun sewu nggih, pak Hans), gambarnya mas Aji yang paling konsisten. Tarikannya bagus, artworknya keren, shadingnya pas, proporsinya ajiib...pokoknya mantep... mbaca beberapa kali cuma liat gambarnya doang enggak bosen :D

delete reply edwinlives4ever wrote on Jul 11 darnia said Dago by Aprilia Sari dan Beng Rahardian Good artwork, but I feel like reading a poem instead of a comic. I'd rather see Beng working on his own stories, which are truly witty.

edit delete reply darnia wrote on Jul 11 edwinlives4ever said Good artwork, but I feel like reading a poem instead of a comic. I'd rather see Beng working on his own stories, which are truly witty. aku agak terganggu dalam pemilihan font dan warnanya... karena panelnya didominasi abu-abu, kalo pake warna hitam enggak keliatan Jadinya ya gitu, Mas..enggak bisa dapet feelnya, sibuk ngebaca, tulisannya apah :D

delete reply depingacygacy wrote on Jul 11 emang komik eropa mcm apa dan? *bukan pengamat dan penikmat komik

edit delete reply darnia wrote on Jul 11 depingacygacy said emang komik eropa mcm apa dan? *bukan pengamat dan penikmat komik Komik Eropa ituh semacam Asterix, Tin Tin dan kanca-kancanya, Mahdep

delete reply edwinlives4ever wrote on Jul 12 depingacygacy said emang komik eropa mcm apa dan? Check those pdf files in my video section. You'll find lots of them.

delete reply edwinlives4ever wrote on Jul 11 darnia said Melati Revolusi oleh Arif Yuntoro dan Pamudji MS. Good idea with bad execution. Some of the soldiers are depicting as shooting assault rifles which are clearly resembling M16. That kind of assault rifle shouldn't have existed until decades later. The grenade looks like a Tornado airsoft grenade. The last scene look like something out of 'drama 17an'.... Too bad. The premise about Malaby's death is actually an interesting one, although nothing new.

edit delete reply darnia wrote on Jul 11 edwinlives4ever said Good idea with bad execution. Some of the soldiers are depicting as shooting assault rifles which are clearly resembling M16. That kind of assault rifle shouldn't have existed until decades later. The grenade looks like a Tornado airsoft grenade. The last scene look like something out of 'drama 17an'.... Too bad. The premise about Malaby's death is actually an interesting one, although nothing new. huahahhahah drama 17-an :D Aku sendiri enggak terlalu memperhatikan kisah yang ini. Mungkin agak keganggu sama artworknya ya *dibacok* Btw, aku sempat ngebaca ROEKMINI jadi ROKMINI *taburin garem* XD

delete reply edwinlives4ever wrote on Jul 11 darnia said Mungkin agak keganggu sama artworknya ya I believe many readers think the same. Myself included.

edit delete reply darnia wrote on Jul 11 edwinlives4ever said I believe many readers think the same. Myself included. tapi bener-bener bikin nostalgia. Komik jamanku SD yang 250 perak dulu gambarnya gitu :D

delete reply edwinlives4ever wrote on Jul 11 darnia said Resonansi Hati by Papillon Studio The story is simple yet very touching. However, the side plot about that girl which later becomes the ending of the main plot makes me think that somewhere along the way the writer ran out of ideas of how to finish this good story.

edit delete reply darnia wrote on Jul 11 edwinlives4ever said The story is simple yet very touching. However, the side plot about that girl which later becomes the ending of the main plot makes me think that somewhere along the way the writer ran out of ideas of how to finish this good story. bwahahahhahahahahha....setujuuuuu!! XD pokoknya asli, endingnya menurutku kurang "menggigit"

delete reply edwinlives4ever wrote on Jul 11, edited on Jul 12 darnia said Cinta di Senja Hari oleh Hans Jaladara Nice story, nice dialogs, nice artwork, nice ending; for those who are not too familiar with Panji Tengkorak series. Still, I think Hans should've left well enough alone. It's like reading about how the story of how Si Buta Dari Gua Hantu series ends. Thank God Ganes TH never created that kind of story.

edit delete reply darnia wrote on Jul 11 edwinlives4ever said Nice story, nice dialogs, nice artwork, nice ending; for those who are not too familiar with Panji Tengkorak series. Still, I think Hans should've left well enough alone. It's like reading about how the story of Si Buta Dari Gua Hantu series ends. Thank God Ganes TH never created that kind of story. Setuju. Aku enggak baca Panji Tengkorak, cuma sekedar tau aja Tapi tetep bisa ngikutin cerita ini. Heh? Trus yang create siapa?

delete reply edwinlives4ever wrote on Jul 11 darnia said Heh? Trus yang create siapa? What?

edit delete reply darnia wrote on Jul 11 edwinlives4ever said What? lha katanya Ganes TH enggak bikin endingnya, tapi mas Edwin bilang menarik baca endingnya Si Buta? Eh, apa gw yang salah maksudnya ya? XD

delete reply edwinlives4ever wrote on Jul 12 darnia said lha katanya Ganes TH enggak bikin endingnya, tapi mas Edwin bilang menarik baca endingnya Si Buta? No. I said that reading Cinta Di Senja Hari is like reading the story of how Si Buta Dari Gua Hantu series ends. I didn't say that such a story exists.

edit delete reply darnia wrote on Jul 12 edwinlives4ever said No. I said that reading Cinta Di Senja Hari is like reading the story of how Si Buta Dari Gua Hantu series ends. I didn't say that such a story exists. makanya aku bilang, kayaknya aku yang nangkepnya salah :D *syungkhem* *mintak angpau*

delete reply edwinlives4ever wrote on Jul 11 darnia said Antara Aku, Sahabatku dan Anak Mamak-ku oleh Jon Kobet. The one with best cultural local content. That's all.

edit delete reply darnia wrote on Jul 11 edwinlives4ever said The one with best cultural local content. That's all. hahhaha perahu pompooooong \(^O^)/

delete reply ibuseno wrote on Jul 11 Api di bukit menoreh.. masih ada gak ya itu komik ?

delete reply edwinlives4ever wrote on Jul 11 ibuseno said Api di bukit menoreh.. masih ada gak ya itu komik ? There is a comic version of Api Di Bukit Menoreh series?

edit delete reply darnia wrote on Jul 11 ibuseno said Api di bukit menoreh.. masih ada gak ya itu komik ? waaahh...malah baru tau kalo ada komiknya :D Taunya dulu sandiwara radio

delete reply ibuseno wrote on Jul 11 darnia said waaahh...malah baru tau kalo ada komiknya :D Taunya dulu sandiwara radio Ada, dulu pernah baca, berseri gitu deh.. trus bukunya juga ada , tebeeell

edit delete reply darnia wrote on Jul 11 ibuseno said Ada, dulu pernah baca, berseri gitu deh.. trus bukunya juga ada , tebeeell aku gak tau kalo gitu, Teh :D mas Edwin kayaknya juga gak tau tuh *ngikik*

delete reply edwinlives4ever wrote on Jul 12 There were several comic spin-off of this series, and even Teguh Santosa made the unfinished comic version of Mahesa Jenar story, but I've never heard of any comic telling the story of the main series.

edit delete reply darnia wrote on Jul 12 edwinlives4ever said There were several comic spin-off of this series, and even Teguh Santosa made the unfinished comic version of Mahesa Jenar story, but I've never heard of any comic telling the story of the main series. hoooo gituuuuu..... Kayak endingnya Doraemon itu yah jadinya?

delete reply edwinlives4ever wrote on Jul 12 darnia said hoooo gituuuuu..... Kayak endingnya Doraemon itu yah jadinya? The ending of Doraemon was not created by the original creator, and it;s not a spin-off; a pastiche more like it. The spin-offs of Api Di Bukit Menoreh were created by SH Mintardja himself. Spin-off refers to subplots within the main story, not the creator.

edit delete reply darnia wrote on Jul 12 edwinlives4ever said The ending of Doraemon was not created by the original creator, and it;s not a spin-off; a pastiche more like it. The spin-offs of Api Di Bukit Menoreh were created by SH Mintardja himself. Spin-off refers to subplots within the main story, not the creator. spin-off itu kayak ending cerita tapi kayak fanfics gitu? Atau modelan gini : pernah baca kalo pengarang Hana Yori Dango setelah merampungkan vol.23 manganya, beliau meninggal. Padahal komiknya sendiri belum tamat. Kemudian, para asistennya bikin lanjutan endingnya. Apakah semacam itu?

delete reply edwinlives4ever wrote on Jul 12 darnia said spin-off itu kayak ending cerita tapi kayak fanfics gitu? NO. Spin-off, referring to stories, is a new story derived from an existing story, sometimes a development of a subplot or secondary character of a story into a more independent story. For example, the movie U.S. Marshals is a spin-off of The Fugitive, The Lone Gunmen TV series is a spin-off of The X-Files, Angel TV series is a spin-off of Buffy The Vampire Slayer, etc.

edit delete reply darnia wrote on Jul 12 edwinlives4ever said NO. Spin-off, referring to stories, is a new story derived from an existing story, sometimes a development of a subplot or secondary character of a story into a more independent story. For example, the movie U.S. Marshals is a spin-off of The Fugitive, The Lone Gunmen TV series is a spin-off of The X-Files, Angel TV series is a spin-off of Buffy The Vampire Slayer, etc. OOOOOOOOOOOO IYAAAA... -- kayaknya dulu pernah dijelasin sama mbak Hanitje -- Aku kira spin-off cuma di pilem doang, ternyata di kancah media cetak juga ada yak :D

delete reply edwinlives4ever wrote on Jul 12 darnia said spin-off cuma di pilem doang, ternyata di kancah media cetak juga ada yak Also in consumer products and even religion.

edit delete reply darnia wrote on Jul 12 edwinlives4ever said Also in consumer products and even religion. jeng jeng jeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeng..... -- eikeh kemana aja yah? -- :O

delete reply depingacygacy wrote on Jul 12 ooo

delete reply martoart wrote on Jul 12 darnia said Beliau ini bertutur tentang perkembangan komik di Indonesia dari masa ke masa. Dan kenapa yang "dipersalahkan" dalam mandeg-nya komik khas Indonesia hanya manga Jepang dan komik Amerika, sedangkan secara halus, komik Eropa malah menyusup ke tengah-tengah kita dengan gencarnya. Namun, tak ada satupun yang mempermasalahkannya, malah merasa bangga bahwa pernah "berkenalan" dengan komik-komik tersebut. Oh ya?.. http://martoart.multiply.com/journal/item/42/Membaca-Komik

edit delete reply darnia wrote on Jul 12 martoart said Oh ya?.. http://martoart.multiply.com/journal/item/42/Membaca-Komik *suceklik*

delete reply ayanapunya wrote on Jul 12 ku komik indonesia taunya yang model siksaan di neraka, dan :D

edit delete reply darnia wrote on Jul 12 ayanapunya said ku komik indonesia taunya yang model siksaan di neraka, dan :D hahahahaha itu juga salah satu komik lokal fenomenal

delete reply museliem wrote on Jul 12 Klo petruk dan gareng itu termasuk komik ga yah??

edit delete reply darnia wrote on Jul 12 museliem said Klo petruk dan gareng itu termasuk komik ga yah?? kayaknya bukan yah? *lirik sesepuh minta bantuan*

delete reply edwinlives4ever wrote on Jul 12, edited on Jul 12 darnia said kayaknya bukan yah? Says who? There were/are several Petruk-Gareng comics out there, such as the ones created by Tatang S, Inri S, and many others.

edit delete reply darnia wrote on Jul 12 edwinlives4ever said Says who? There were/are several Petruk-Gareng comics out there, such as the ones created by Tatang S, Inri S, and many others. oiya....dulu kayaknya punya satu -- self-poke -- XD Thanks for the correction, mas Edwin

delete reply museliem wrote on Jul 12 edwinlives4ever said Says who? There were/are several Petruk-Gareng comics out there, such as the ones created by Tatang S, Inri S, and many others. Iya itu punyanya tatang S.... tapi memang modelnya kayak TTS gitu, sedangkan format komik yang gue kenal yah sejenis doraemon, breakshot dll.

edit delete reply darnia wrote on Jul 12 museliem said Iya itu punyanya tatang S.... tapi memang modelnya kayak TTS gitu, sedangkan format komik yang gue kenal yah sejenis doraemon, breakshot dll. Emang dulu gak baca semodel Smurf, Asterix gitu, Oom?

delete reply museliem wrote on Jul 12 darnia said Emang dulu gak baca semodel Smurf, Asterix gitu, Oom? Kenalnya pas udah SMP.... itupun taunya pas datang ke penjualan majalah bekas hahahaa

edit delete reply darnia wrote on Jul 12 museliem said Kenalnya pas udah SMP.... itupun taunya pas datang ke penjualan majalah bekas hahahaa hahahha iyaa... gw dulu masih SD, suka beli. Masih 3000 pas SMU pengen punya lagi, harganya udah 28000 Langsung cabut ke loakan deh, dapet 3000-an second, tapi kadang gak ada sampulnya XD

delete reply larass wrote on Jul 12 dulu aku sukanya petruk hehe

edit delete reply darnia wrote on Jul 12 larass said dulu aku sukanya petruk hehe kenapa tuh, Mbak Laras? Ada filosofi si Petruk yang ngena banget di ati? :D -- keinget kumpulan featurenya Sindhunata yang "Petruk Jadi Raja" --

delete reply larass wrote on Jul 12 engggak sih lucu ajah kadang nyelehi juga hahaha

edit delete reply darnia wrote on Jul 12 larass said engggak sih lucu ajah kadang nyelehi juga hahaha aku malah lupa lho, Petruk dulu karakternya kayak apa XD

delete reply ninelights wrote on Jul 12 tadi aku komen di sini, terus coba ku copas di word, ehla ko dhowo, Dan. :| Tar kuposting di jurnal aja deh yah... kalo inget tapi... *merenges*

edit delete reply darnia wrote on Jul 12 ninelights said tadi aku komen di sini, terus coba ku copas di word, ehla ko dhowo, Dan. :| Tar kuposting di jurnal aja deh yah... kalo inget tapi... *merenges* INGETLAH!!!!! -- panggil Agung Herkules becelana polkadot pink belang-belang --

delete reply larass wrote on Jul 12 hahahaha sebenarnya mereka hanya ingin sentilan yg lelucon yg notabene selalu ada di kehidupan masyarakat

edit delete reply darnia wrote on Jul 12 larass said hahahaha sebenarnya mereka hanya ingin sentilan yg lelucon yg notabene selalu ada di kehidupan masyarakat dulu nonton Punakawan cuma di Ria Jenaka, TVRI hari Minggu pagi itu cuma karena masih kecil, enggak terlalu nangkep guyonannya :)

delete reply edwinlives4ever wrote on Jul 12, edited on Jul 12 darnia said Ria Jenaka, TVRI hari Minggu pagi itu cuma karena masih kecil, enggak terlalu nangkep guyonannya :) They were funny only in the beginning. Later the were too busy delivering messages from the government's propaganda corps.

edit delete reply darnia wrote on Jul 12 edwinlives4ever said They were funny only in the beginning. Later the were too busy delivering messages from the government's propaganda corps. errrgh.... pity :( padahal wajah-wajahnya aku inget banget

delete reply roelworks wrote on Jul 12 om crow penggemar setia aji :D

delete reply edwinlives4ever wrote on Jul 12 roelworks said om crow penggemar setia aji :D And that's why I'm honest enough to reveal some of his mistakes.

edit delete reply darnia wrote on Jul 12 edwinlives4ever said And that's why I'm honest enough to reveal some of his mistakes. fans sejati :>

edit delete reply darnia wrote on Jul 12 roelworks said om crow penggemar setia aji :D ho oh

delete reply roelworks wrote on Jul 13 arif yuntoro yang ini bukan sih? https://www.facebook.com/arief.yuntoro

edit delete reply darnia wrote on Jul 13, edited on Jul 13 roelworks said arif yuntoro yang ini bukan sih? https://www.facebook.com/arief.yuntoro hiks...enggak kebuka T^T cuma kalo liat model gambarnya kayaknya bukan (lupa di Melati Revolusi yang gambar siapa) edit : yang ditaut mas Roel kayaknya Arief Yuntoro yang ini juga : http://komikoo.com/users/palagan

delete reply edwinlives4ever wrote on Jul 13 darnia said palagan That sounds like it refers to Ambarawa, the home of Pamudji MS.

edit delete reply darnia wrote on Jul 13 edwinlives4ever said That sounds like it refers to Ambarawa, the home of Pamudji MS. Tapi di profilnya, namanya Arief Yuntoro :D

delete reply edwinlives4ever wrote on Jul 13 darnia said Tapi di profilnya, namanya Arief Yuntoro :D I know. I mentioned Pamudji MS because I know that he lives in Amabarawa, and I think it's possible that they're both from Ambarawa.

delete reply edwinlives4ever wrote on Jul 13 darnia said lupa di Melati Revolusi yang gambar siapa I thought it was drawn by Pamudji MS, the style is rather similar to his Badai Laut Selatan (story by Kho Ping Hoo). And that would explain the lack of research.

delete reply roelworks wrote on Jul 13 Arief sih kenal ... kayaknya basenya di Jakarta, deh ..

delete reply edwinlives4ever wrote on Jul 13 roelworks said Arief sih kenal ... kayaknya basenya di Jakarta, deh .. Is he originally from Ambarawa? Or, has he spent some time there?

delete reply roelworks wrote on Jul 13 again i haven't met him for years...but these days everbody is scattered around not necessarily concentrated in one place to produce something

edit delete reply darnia wrote on Jul 13 kayaknya bisa reunian yah kalo baca komik kolaborasi kayak gitu :D